IdentityForce vs. LifeLock: Which One Is Better In 2024?

September 4, 2024

8

 Minute Read

In this article:

    Shield Icon

    Identity theft and fraud protection for your finances, personal info, and devices.

    Get Identity Guard

    Is IdentityForce Better Than LifeLock?

    IdentityForce and LifeLock are two of the best identity theft protection services out there — each offering its own combination of monitoring and protection tools to help keep you and your family safe from scammers.

    But while the two platforms offer similar services, there are critical differences you should know about before picking one over the other.  

    Aside from comprehensive identity monitoring, IdentityForce places heavy emphasis on credit monitoring, while LifeLock provides robust antivirus and digital security tools through its protection plans with Norton 360. 

    The biggest differences between IdentityForce and LifeLock are that: 

    • IdentityForce plans are more expensive, but include more credit protection and simulation tools (when you opt for the credit-bundled plan).
    • LifeLock offers a cheaper introductory plan but reserves critical credit monitoring features, higher insurance coverage, and digital security for its more expensive plan.
    🏆 Get an award-winning alternative to IdentityForce and LifeLock. Identity Guard was rated 5-stars by Forbes Advisor for its powerful identity theft and fraud protection. Save up to 50% on Identity Guard and give yourself peace of mind.

    IdentityForce vs. LifeLock: Head-to-Head Comparison

    IdentityForce
    LifeLock
    Best for
    Individuals and families looking to maintain their credit health.
    Individuals and families that want identity and credit monitoring with high insurance coverage.
    Price (monthly)
    Starts at $19.90/month.
    Starts at $11.99/month.
    Price (annually)
    Starts at $199.90/year.
    Starts at $89.99/year (but increases to $124.99 after the first year).
    Identity monitoring
    Robust identity monitoring that has been highly rated by Top Ten Reviews and ASecureLife.
    Extensive monitoring that includes Dark Web and public records monitoring and data breach notifications.
    Credit monitoring
    No credit monitoring on the standard individual plan.

    Three-bureau credit monitoring is available on the UltraSecure+Credit plans.
    One-bureau credit monitoring with Equifax on standard plans.

    Three-bureau credit monitoring is available on the Ultimate Plus plan.
    Identity theft insurance
    $1 million in coverage on the standard plan, or $2 million on the UltraSecure+Credit plan.
    Up to $3 million in coverage per adult (on the Ultimate Plus plan).
    Digital security tools
    Online protection tools for PCs only. A VPN for mobile devices.
    Available only with the LifeLock with Norton 360 bundle (for an additional cost).
    Customer ratings
    4.2 stars on Trustpilot [*]
    4.6 stars on Trustpilot [*]

    Both IdentityForce and LifeLock provide solid identity monitoring and protection, but the service you choose ultimately depends on which you value more highly: credit protection or digital security tools.

    IdentityForce’s UltraSecure+Credit plan provides advanced credit tracking and simulation tools that you won’t get with LifeLock. But LifeLock offers stronger device protection and digital security due to its partnership with Norton 360 — though this protection comes at an additional cost.

    IdentityForce Review: Best Features, Pros & Cons, and Pricing

    IdentityForce is an identity protection service that was founded in 2005. It has since been acquired by TransUnion (one of the three major credit bureaus) and is highly rated as one of the best identity protection services.

    IdentityForce offers two different plan tiers — with options to protect just yourself or you and your family (two adults and up to 10 children). The UltraSecure plan includes identity and PC protection but no credit monitoring features. The UltraSecure+Credit plan bundles credit monitoring with the standard plan’s identity protection features.

    Regardless of which plan you choose, IdentityForce has one glaring drawback when stacked up against competitors: price. Even its most basic plan with limited features is double or triple the cost of competitors offering more features.

    Here are IdentityForce’s plans & pricing as of September 2024:

    • UltraSecure Individual: $19.90/month
    • UltraSecure+Credit Individual: $34.90/month
    • UltraSecure Family: $24.90/month
    • UltraSecure+Credit Family: $39.90/month

    While IdentityForce is more expensive than most identity protection providers out there, it does offer a free 30-day trial on its UltraSecure plans. This allows you to get a feel for the service before investing in its more expensive credit bundle plan.

    Pros
    Cons
    Personalized identity safety scores and action plans based on your risk level.
    Pricing is steeper than competitors, and there’s no money-back guarantee.
    Useful credit tracking and simulation tools to help you improve your score.
    No credit scores or credit report monitoring included with the cheapest plan.
    Monitors social media accounts for signs of fraud.
    No parental controls included with family plans.

    You should choose IdentityForce if:

    • You only want to protect your PC. IdentityForce offers a suite of digital security tools to protect you while you browse, shop, and bank online. The caveat is that these tools are only available for PCs, not mobile devices.
    • Monitoring your credit is your primary concern. IdentityForce offers three-bureau credit monitoring, monthly credit scores, and a credit score simulator on its UltraSecure+Credit plan so you can keep your credit health top of mind.
    • You’re not ready to commit to an identity protection provider just yet. IdentityForce offers a 30-day free trial, which is more than many competitors offer and allows plenty of time to test out its features before purchasing a subscription.

    📚 Related: Identity Guard vs. IdentityForce Comparison and Showdown

    LifeLock Review: Best Features, Pros & Cons, and Pricing

    Founded in 2005, LifeLock is one of the most well-known identity protection providers, claiming to serve more than 80 million users worldwide.

    LifeLock offers three different plan tiers, with options for individuals, families, and families with children, as well as an optional Norton 360 add-on. All this leads to a confusing array of plan options with no real online guidance available to help you decide which plan is best for you. 

    Regardless of which LifeLock plan you opt for, you’ll get identity and Social Security number (SSN) alerts, one or three-bureau monitoring, home title and 401(k) monitoring, social media fraud alerts, and more. LifeLock also offers some of the highest insurance coverage in the industry — up to $3 million per adult on family plans.

    LifeLock’s standard plans focus on identity and credit monitoring; but if you also want to protect your devices and online activity, you’ll need to purchase the LifeLock with Norton 360 bundle.

    Here are LifeLock’s plans & pricing for individuals (without Norton 360) as of September 2024:

    • Standard: $11.99/month
    • Advantage: $22.99/month
    • Ultimate Plus: $34.99/month

    Keep in mind that if you opt for LifeLock’s discounted annual plans, the listed prices are only for your first year as a customer. After that, you’ll be paying anywhere from 30–50+% more for your plan. For example, LifeLock Ultimate Plus for two adults costs $395.88/year for the first year and $679.99/year after that.

    Pros
    Cons
    Credit monitoring and identity monitoring with apps for both iOS and Android devices.
    Massive renewal price increases occur after your first year of service.
    Optional integration with Norton 360 for access to digital security tools — at an additional cost.
    Multiple security and legal issues in recent years, including nearly one million compromised user accounts from Norton’s password manager [*].
    Up to $3 million in insurance coverage on its most expensive tier (only $1 million in stolen funds reimbursement).
    Complex plan options can leave you vulnerable or lead you to overpay for services you don’t need.

    You should choose LifeLock if:

    • You want flexibility in plan options. LifeLock offers three tiers of plans each for individuals, families, and households with kids. It also has annual plan options, which will save you some money compared to paying monthly.
    • You want more insurance coverage. LifeLock’s Ultimate Plus plan offers $3,000,000 in identity theft coverage — triple the industry standard of $1 million.
    • You’re looking for a recognizable household name. LifeLock has been around since 2005 and holds a Trustpilot rating of 4.6 stars. LifeLock is also partnered with Norton 360, another household name, to offer a digital security suite to its customers.

    📚 Related: Identity Guard vs. LifeLock Comparison and Showdown

    Is Identity Guard Better Than Both LifeLock and IdentityForce?

    IdentityForce and LifeLock are both solid products, but they have drawbacks and compromise on certain features that could potentially put you at risk.

    Identity Guard has been providing award-winning identity theft protection for more than two decades. With robust identity and credit monitoring, Safe Browsing tools, and accommodating family plans that cover up to five adults, Identity Guard can keep your family safe at just a fraction of the cost of IdentityForce or LifeLock. 

    You’ll also get 24/7 access to U.S.-based customer support and identity restoration specialists, as well as a 60-day money-back guarantee on all annual plans. 

    And with the Identity Guard mobile app, you’ll have convenient access to all of these features at your fingertips.

    Identity Guard
    IdentityForce
    LifeLock
    Starts at $4.49/month.
    Starts at $19.90/month.
    Starts at $7.50/month — price increases by 37% after your first year.
    Award-winning identity theft protection, including investment account monitoring, home title monitoring, and more (Ultra plan).
    Includes risk scores for any of your personal data found compromised on the Dark Web.
    Includes Dark Web and public records monitoring, data breach notifications, social media monitoring, and more.
    Three-bureau credit monitoring (Total and Ultra plans).
    Three-bureau credit monitoring (UltraSecure+Credit plan).
    Three-bureau credit monitoring (Ultimate Plus plan).
    $1 million in insurance coverage per adult (up to $5 million on family plans).
    $2 million in insurance coverage (UltraSecure+Credit plan).
    $3 million in insurance coverage per adult.
    Safe Browsing tools and password manager.
    Mobile VPN and online protection tools for PCs only.
    Digital security tools available with Norton 360 add-on.

    Now, let’s take a closer look at how all of these services compare with the features that matter most:

    Identity monitoring

    Identity monitoring is the very core of what identity theft protection services provide. A good service should monitor for your information in a variety of places and be able to alert you quickly if your identity could be compromised.

    Both IdentityForce and LifeLock provide comprehensive identity monitoring — including financial accounts, social media, court records, sex offender lists, and Dark Web monitoring. IdentityForce also provides you with a “risk score” for each instance in which your personal information has been found on the Dark Web so that you can better understand the seriousness of the compromise.

    Identity Guard provides similar protection, but the level of monitoring you get depends on your plan. For example, the Ultra plan includes data breach notifications and Dark Web monitoring, as well as monitoring of financial accounts, credit card transactions, investment accounts, home titles, social media, public records, and more.

    The bottom line: IdentityForce, LifeLock, and Identity Guard are all solid choices for identity monitoring.

    Credit monitoring

    One of the biggest risks of identity theft is if scammers are able to take out credit or open new accounts in your name. Credit monitoring tracks activity on your credit files and alerts you of suspicious activity. 

    Both IdentityForce and LifeLock require you to be subscribed to their highest plan tier in order to get credit monitoring with all three of the major credit bureaus. If you’re subscribed to one of the cheaper plans, you’ll still receive some protection — but you’ll be vulnerable to fraud that happens with the bureaus that aren’t being monitored.

    Identity Guard offers three-bureau credit monitoring and monthly credit scores on its mid-tier plan. If you upgrade to the Ultra plan, you also get annual credit reports from each of the three bureaus and the ability to easily lock or unlock your Experian credit file.

    The bottom line: Yes, IdentityForce, LifeLock, and Identity Guard all offer three-bureau credit monitoring, but not on their most basic plans. Overall, Identity Guard’s Total plan with three-bureau monitoring works out to be the cheapest.

    Support and insurance

    If you’re a victim of identity theft, the last thing you want is to be stuck dealing with the fallout on your own. The industry standard for identity protection providers is $1 million in insurance coverage. Identity Guard offers $1 million per adult, for a total of up to $5 million on family plans.

    IdentityForce offers $1 million in coverage on its most basic plan, and $2 million if you upgrade to the credit bundle package.

    The coverage you get with LifeLock greatly depends on your specific plan. For example, Lifelock’s standard plans only cover up to $25,000 in personal expenses and stolen funds reimbursement. But if you’re subscribed to the Ultimate Plus plan, you’ll get $3 million in coverage per adult.

    The bottom line: If you’re looking for a service that offers the most ID theft insurance coverage, LifeLock is the best choice. However, many customers have complained about poor customer service when reaching out to LifeLock for help [*].

    Online safety

    While IdentityForce offers a suite of digital security tools to help protect you against threats, there’s one major caveat: those tools are only available for PCs. IdentityForce does offer a virtual private network (VPN) that you can use on any device, but that’s the extent of protection available for multiple devices.

    LifeLock offers online safety tools for mobile devices as well as PCs; but to access them, you need to pay extra for the LifeLock with Norton 360 bundle.

    Every Identity Guard plan comes equipped with a secure password manager and Safe Browsing tools to help protect you against phishing scams and keep you safe online. With the Ultra plan, you also receive alerts if a hacker is trying to log in to your social media accounts.

    The bottom line: When it comes to cybersecurity online, Identity Guard offers the most value for your money with a password manager and Safe Browsing tools available on all plans at no extra cost to you.

    Pricing

    When selecting an identity theft protection provider, pricing is one of the most important factors. Most identity protection providers have plans that are priced similarly, but the value and exact features you get can vastly differ.

    For example, Identity Guard offers the cheapest monthly plans at just $4.49/month. Even its mid-tier plan is relatively inexpensive at $9.99/month and offers the most comprehensive protection compared to similarly priced IdentityForce and LifeLock plans.

    Starting at $19.90/month for individuals, IdentityForce is by far the most expensive option of the three. LifeLock appears to be inexpensive at first glance, but there’s a catch — subscription costs increase by up to 37% after the first year.

    The bottom line: IdentityForce’s pricing is very steep, and LifeLock’s plans lack transparency with an unexpected price increase after the first year. Identity Guard offers the same features at just a fraction of the cost — and pricing is completely transparent.

    💪 Get award-winning protection without breaking the bank. Identity Guard offers some of the best protection against fraud, scams, and identity theft — with plans starting at just $4.49/month.

    The Final Verdict: Identity Guard Offers Better Peace of Mind

    While IdentityForce offers decent protection against some types of fraud and scams, its features aren’t comprehensive enough to keep you safe from the most sophisticated cybercriminals.

    LifeLock is a trusted household name and offers comprehensive protection through its partnership with Norton 360. However, its subscription prices increase so much after the first year that it may have you questioning whether it’s actually worth the cost.

    Identity Guard offers more robust monitoring services and coverage than IdentityForce or LifeLock at a much lower price point. Identity Guard plans include award-winning identity monitoring, Dark web monitoring, social media account takeover alerts, and more.

    Save when you sign up for Identity Guard today — plans start at $4.49/month

    Related Articles

    A woman holding a phone with a lock symbol on the screen

    Is LifeLock Worth the Price? How To Decide in 2024

    LifeLock is one of the most well-known brands in identity theft protection — but recent security issues could mean it’s not the best choice for you.

    Read More

    March 1, 2024

    Is LifeLock Worth the Price? How To Decide in 2024
    A finger tapping on an illustrated log-in screen

    The Best Identity Guard Alternatives in 2024: 7 Options

    Learn about the top seven Identity Guard alternatives so you can make an informed decision about which identity theft protection service is right for you.

    Read More

    January 9, 2024

    The Best Identity Guard Alternatives in 2024: 7 Options

    Get Started with Identity Guard

    Get started with Identity Guard today, risk-free.

    Get Protected Today
    1. Financial identity theft and fraud
    2. Medical identity theft
    3. Child identity theft
    4. Elder fraud and estate identity theft
    5. “Friendly” or familial identity theft
    6. Employment identity theft
    7. Criminal identity theft
    8. Tax identity theft
    9. Unemployment and government benefits identity theft
    10. Synthetic identity theft
    11. Identity cloning
    12. Account takeovers (social media, email, etc.)
    13. Social Security number identity theft
    14. Biometric ID theft
    15. Crypto account takeovers